Three different problems produce the same symptoms (extruder clicking, weak or no extrusion):
Partial clog: debris partially blocks the nozzle bore. Some plastic still flows but not enough.
Full clog: debris fully blocks the nozzle. No plastic flows even when manually pushed.
Heat creep: filament softens *above* the melt zone (in the heat break) and jams there. Symptoms identical to a clog but the actual blockage is somewhere different.
Fixes are different. Cold-pulling clears partial clogs but does nothing for heat creep. Replacing the nozzle fixes a worn nozzle but not a failed hotend cooling fan. Diagnose first - then you spend 5 minutes fixing instead of 2 hours guessing.
When To Use It / When Not To
Diagnose when: the extruder is clicking or grinding, extrusion is thin, prints are starting fine then degrading, or the nozzle suddenly stopped extruding entirely.
Skip diagnosis and replace nozzle when: you've already done multiple cold pulls and the symptoms persist, or you've printed many hours of abrasive filament on a brass nozzle (worn, not clogged).
Step By Step
Run through these checks in order:
1. When did symptoms start?
- Right after switching filament: incompatible material residue. Cold-pull at the higher of the two filaments' temperatures.
- After leaving printer hot but idle: carbonised debris. Cold-pull at the appropriate temp.
- During a long print (first 30 min fine, then degrades): heat creep. Skip to step 4.
- Suddenly during a print, no warning: partial clog or extruder grinding. Continue to step 2.
2. Try manual extrusion at print temp.
- Heat to print temp. From the LCD, command 50 mm extrusion.
- Filament extrudes cleanly: not a clog. Check extruder tension and gear teeth.
- Filament extrudes thin: partial clog. Cold pull (see how-to-do-cold-pull).
- Filament doesn't extrude at all: continue to step 3.
3. Check the extruder.
- Open the extruder case. Inspect the gear teeth - are they covered in plastic dust? Pellet-shaped pieces of filament? That's grinding.
- Pellets means the gear is failing to grip the filament - either the filament is too soft (TPU), the tension is wrong, or the gear teeth are worn. Adjust tension or replace gear.
- Clean the gear teeth, push filament through manually with the lever held open. If it pushes through to the nozzle but doesn't come out, it's a full clog.
- Full clog: cold-pull aggressively. If still blocked after 5 pulls, replace the nozzle.
4. If symptoms develop over the course of a long print: heat creep diagnosis.
- Listen to the hotend cooling fan (the small one *above* the heat break, not the part fan). It should be running constantly during printing.
- If you don't hear it or it sounds like it's struggling: failed fan. Replace ($3-10).
- If the fan is running but you can feel little air movement: dust blocking the heat sink. Clean.
- If both fan and airflow are fine: retraction distance too high pulling softened plastic into the cold zone. Reduce retraction (Bowden 2-3 mm, direct 0.5-1 mm).
- If you upgraded to all-metal hotend: PLA at >215C is heat-creep-prone on all-metal. Drop to 205C.
5. Confirm the diagnosis with a test print.
- Print a small object at default settings.
- If the cold pull / fan replacement / retraction adjustment fixed it, you diagnosed correctly.
- If symptoms return, escalate: nozzle replacement, hotend disassembly, or hardware-level debugging.
Common Mistakes To Avoid
Assuming every extrusion problem is a clog. Heat creep, extruder grinding, e-step miscalibration, and worn nozzles all look similar. Diagnose first.
Replacing the nozzle without trying cold pulls. A new nozzle costs $1-5 but takes 10 minutes to swap and re-calibrate. Cold pulls cost nothing and take 2 minutes - try first.
Skipping the hotend fan check on long-print failures. If symptoms scale with print time, it's heat creep until proven otherwise. Don't fix retraction, don't replace nozzle - check the fan.
Ignoring extruder grinding. Pellets near the extruder mean the gear is slipping. Cold-pulls won't help; you need to fix the extruder grip first.
Related Guides And Tools
Once diagnosed, jump to the right fix: how-to-do-cold-pull (partial clogs), how-to-change-nozzle (full or worn nozzle), or clogging-heat-creep (heat creep). For broader extrusion troubleshooting, see under-extrusion.
Recommended Settings
Manual Extrude Test50 mm at print temp
Heat Creep IndicatorSymptoms scale with print time
Partial Clog FixCold pull (3-5x)
Full Clog FixCold pull then nozzle replace
Heat Creep FixHotend fan + reduce retraction
Grinding FixAdjust extruder tension or replace gear